Quite simply, a citizenship by investment scheme is one that enables wealthy individuals and families to fast track naturalization in a new country.
Cynics tend to suggest that these individuals are simply using their wealth to buy citizenship. However, very few countries want to be tarred with a label of passports for sale, so there are always criteria for applicants to satisfy to ensure that only highly appropriate candidates apply.
These criteria differ from country to country, but any legitimate immigration scheme will include a minimum period of residency in the country to create and demonstrate ties, plus some form of background check or vetting. Most second citizenship by investment countries also want applicants to purchase or rent long-term valuable residential property. Some countries also ask that government bonds are purchased, or that a contribution is made to a fund that benefits the country. A few economic citizenship schemes1 also require some form of business investment that employs locals.
Most of these rules have come about because of the experience learned from previous passport programs. For example, there have been “no questions asked” schemes in the past where a new passport would be issued in exchange for a large payment. These countries soon developed a bad reputation and their passports were soon being bought by criminals and gangsters. No matter how broke a country might be, nobody wants that reputation!
Small nations actually want to be seen as a haven for high net worth families and individuals, people of talent and education.
It is worth pointing out at this early stage that not all passports2 are the same. For example, some countries have very few reciprocal travel or visa arrangements, while others enable visa free travel to most of the world.
Equally, citizens of some countries are expected to perform national service, while most are not. Some countries place quite a high level of taxation on their subjects, some place no taxes on their citizens, whilst most nations lie somewhere in between.
In other words, there are options for a family to naturalize into a second country and some countries will be more appealing that others, depending upon the circumstances of the applicants.
For governments – usually smaller nations – it is important to investigate options for raising income. Many smaller nations already operate to a greater or lesser degree in the world of offshore finance or investment, so passports can seem like a logical next step. Ultimately, a passport is a relatively inexpensive document to produce, despite the much higher value it has.
Who Wants Citizenship By Investment And Why?
There are many reasons why an individual or family might wish to have a second (or third) passport. For many, it is simply diversification. Once your net worth and income reach a certain level, you have a luxury apartment in London and one in Paris, then what?
An obvious next step is to add extra security to your personal freedom. It might be an escape option in case your country ever goes to war or there is a change in government that brings in rules that limit freedom.
For others, they already live in countries where personal freedom is limited. Now that they have accumulated some assets, it is time to loosen those shackles. Economic citizenship may enable the children to be educated in America or Europe, for example. Reasons like these can make the investment worthwhile.
Many people are less philosophical about these things and simply see second citizenship by investment or dual nationality as a way to reduce their tax burdens.
Why Is It So Difficult To Learn About Citizenship By Investment?
There are several answers to this question. Firstly, there are very few lawyers that are genuinely international. There are obviously many international law firms and practices, but most lawyers sit exams and qualifications in one country. This means that there are many attorneys that understand the laws of their own country, but few are qualified or licensed to advise beyond that.
As a topic, this market is dominated by professionals that mostly work by referral from other firms and consultants. The very wealthy tend not to expect to find the best advice in a Quora or reddit thread, in a wiki or a YouTube video. They are much more likely to ask their wealth manager or consultant to refer several lawyers or attorneys and review their proposals than to read online reviews and explanations.
By speaking to a lawyer or attorney, letting them explain options and solutions and then taking time to compare and review their offers, perhaps in a Malta vs Cyprus type scenario, the wealthy are able to only buy the best and most suitable passport for their needs.
If you are genuinely wealthy and reading this page, it is worth considering whether you ought to be taking legal advice from a trusted and competent advisor, letting that person review and understand your circumstances and letting them refer the best and most suitable offers to you. It is certainly true that no matter how well meaning, a blog post, YouTube video, reddit or quora thread or wikipedia page, will be able to give the personalised explanation that is needed.
What Criteria Make Citizenship By Investment Countries Popular?
There are many countries whose passport is not a particularly helpful travel document, meaning that only the truly desparate and career criminals would apply for one. In contrast, there are other countries with very powerful passports3 that most people would be interested in.
Some criteria for selecting a nation for naturalization might include:
– Is the country an EU member state? EU citizens are allowed visa free travel and the right to reside in all EU member states as a fundamental right. When this is combined with the rights of movement under the Schengen Agreement, it provides powerful benefits to lifestyle and freedom.
– Is the country “neutral”? Some nations have a fairly bad reputation around the world whilst some others are thought of incredibly well. For example, the reputation of Ireland seems to be very good everywhere. If you are going to be associated with a new country, it might as well be a country that is generally liked. It will make life much easier.
– Are citizens required to perform some sort of national or military service? You might want to serve in an army, but lots of people do not.
– How does the citizenship by investment country tax it’s residents? On top of any costs to apply will be the costs of actually being there. Taxation is generally one of the highest bills we have to pay, so it makes sense to investigate the situation carefully. Your income and it’s source will differ from that of many other people, so it is important to consider this question and your own circumstances carefully.
– What is the national language? Will you be able to function there with the language that you speak? For most people, finding a country where a sizable portion of the population speaks English is very important. This makes many of the Caribbean islands attractive.
– How long is the application process? Having to wait one year is very different to having to wait five years.
Considering that there are almost 200 sovereign nations in the world, these simple criteria limit the number of attractive countries quite considerably.
Which Countries Give Citizenship By Investment?
There are few identifying characteristics that can be used to quickly categorise these countries. In the mind of the general population, a country that sells a passport is usually a small island in a sunny far away place, but the reality that there are many some first world nations that provide economic citizenship.
Outside of the EU, there are a number of schemes to investigate:
Antigua and Barbuda
– a passport that is valid for 5 years
– visa free travel to 100+ countries
– time required is 2-4 months
– minimum investment: from $200,000
St Kitts and Nevis
– no dual citizenship restrictions
– visa free travel to Schengen countries and the UK
– no residency requirements or taxation
– minimum investment: from $250,000
– the EB5 Green Card Program
– enables permanent residency status with citizenship granted after 5 years
– investment required for a minimum of 4 years
– minimum investment range: from $500,000 to $1million
Which EU Countries Give Citizenship By Investment?
– the Belgium Business Program
– no residency requirement
– citizenship granted after 5 years
– no dual citizenship restrictions
– minimum investment: 350,000 euros
– Investment Program for Residence and Citizenship
– 1 year minimum residency
– options to invest in local businesses, real estate or government bonds
– minimum investment range: 125,000 to 500,000 euros
– no residency requirement
– time required 3-4 months
– 100% real estate investment possible
– minimum investment: 2.5 million euros
– known as the Individual Investor Programme
– visa free travel to 180+ countries
– no need to actually live in Malta
– time required is 12 months
– minimum investment: from 1 million euros (including an investment in government bonds which can be sold later)
– Golden Residence Visa
– citizenship granted after 6 years
– the minimum residency requirement is just 7 days per year
– minimum investment: 500,000 euros (some of which will be in the form of real estate)
– UK Tier 1 Investor Programme
– minimum investment: from £2 million
As you can see, there are many options available to a high net worth individual or family. However, those words are the key ones – high net worth – because whilst countries describe themselves as wanting to attract creative and talented people, the reality is that they need to have been creative and talented enough to earn and save significant amounts of money.
If you qualify, then there will be many doors open to your family and a new passport may be possible.
Are There Any Disadvantages?
It would seem that there are some potential disadvantages, depending upon the country and individual in question. For example, some people simply do not fit the normal ethnic profile of a well known nationality. This could create potential problems when crossing a border or at an airport. A related issue is that some of the nations that offer economic citizenship are very small, meaning that a new citizen might stand out because the population is not diverse enough. For example, we all know that the population of America contains people with heritage from everywhere on earth. Any person you suggest could potentially be an American citizen. Could you say the same thing for Antigua?
Another potential problem would relate to beginning an application process and for some reason being unable to complete it. For example, some nations require the founding of businesses that generate employment for locals. What if the business idea does not work out? What if some form of rule or circumstance prevents it from even being launched properly? Under such circumstances, it is easy to imagine that investments, application fees and lawyers fees would be lost. This could be a very expensive mistake.
There are also possible reputational issues to counter. While these would not reduce a person’s legal rights, the EU citizenship by investment schemes are coming under renewed pressure from Brussels since early 2018.
Can Anyone Apply?
The rules are obviously different for each country, but generally, most people can apply. The exceptions relate to those outside of the global community. Therefore, citizens where some form of economic sanctions exists against their country – such as North Korea – or failed states – such as Somalia – cannot apply.
There are also people that have international sanctions open against them personally that cannot apply. In theory, each country tells the world that there is a background check to ensure that no undesirables are granted a passport, but it is not always clear that these rules are followed.
It would be hoped that each country would have some pride and be worried that international criminals, for example, might obtain their documents and then be caught breaking laws, but it seems that many countries have no such fears. There are many third world nations where both genuine and fake passports can be purchased quite easily. There are obviously risks associated with using such a document, which is why only purchasing from a verified scheme is recommended.
This is one reason why personal interviews are always a part of any legitimate application process. There have been countries who back in the 1980s and 1990s were notorious for selling documents to anyone with enough money. There were cases uncovered where passports were granted to people serving jail time! Those days have passed and citizenship by investment is now a much more responsible and respectable sector.
It might also be worth pointing out that these schemes are designed only for the wealthy. Each nation has it’s own rules relating to how and when natualization is possible at no cost. There are no scholarships or discounts on these natualization by investment schemes. No matter what a government or Prime Minister may say about “attracting talent”, if the talent does not have enough money they will not be accepted.
Proof Of Funds Will Be Required
The issues mentioned above mean that since the 1990s most governments have agreed to comply with anti-money laundering and KYC (Know Your Client) rules. These apply to all large purchases and should also apply to money used in passport purchasing schemes. Applicants will need to prove that their money is legitimate tax paid money (from investment or salary) and that they are proper and respectable people.
Citizenship By Investment Scheme Comparison
At the time of writing in mid 2018, any citizenship by investment scheme comparison can only look at a small number of programs. Those programs are based either within the European Union, or are a Caribbean island.
It needs to be pointed out that the needs of each individual and family are different, which makes any type of overview comparison very difficult. For example, to most people, a one year minimum residency period ought to be quite acceptable, but there will be some for whom this is literally impossible. For others, the overall cost will be a vital consideration – is there such a thing as value for money citizenship by investment? It is also worth noting that each of the citizenship by investment schemes has multiple options which can complicate matters. Therefore, please seek out specialized advice for your personal situation before making any major financial decisions.
Citizenship By Investment Price Comparison
Bulgaria: BGN1 million investment for 5 years into a government bond portfolio. This is currently around €510,000. After 5 years the full investment will be returned.
Cyprus: €500,000 contribution into the country’s Research and Technology Fund, plus €2 million purchase of shares or bonds in the State Investment Company.
Malta: €650,000 donation into the National Development and Social Fund, plus €150,000 investment into government bonds and either a minimum property purchase (€350,000) or rental for 5 years.
Antigua and Barbuda: US$200,000 contribution to the National Development Fund.
Grenada: US$250,000 real estate investment.
St Kitts and Nevis: US$150,000 contribution to the Sustainable Growth Fund.
Citizenship By Investment Residency Period Comparison
Bulgaria: Six to nine months. Special exemption from physical residency provided by law.
Cyprus: Three months with no requirement to spend a minimum number of days in the country.
Malta: One year minimum residency with no requirement to spend a minimum number of days in the country, plus five year property ownership or rental.
Antigua and Barbuda: No minimum requirement.
Grenada: No minimum requirement.
St Kitts and Nevis: 60 day processing possible.
Citizenship By Investment Visa Free Travel Comparison
(Details to the best of our knowledge at the end of 2017.)
Bulgaria: 156 countries
Cyprus: 163 countries
Malta: 173 countries
Antigua and Barbuda: 140 countries
Grenada: 131 countries
St Kitts and Nevis: 141 countries